The Visura Media Blog

Organization
    
Location: Brooklyn
Biography: The Visura (Vē-su’-ra: Be seen) Blog features Visura highlights, essays, and announcements—including grants, partnerships, events and open call opportunities and results. 
News Reframe v_features
Reframe | Stephen Mayes & The State of Photojournalism, Part I
written by clary estes for the visura media blog
Aug 25, 2019

Editor's note: The Reframe Column is a series of essays and interviews aimed at examining new media and visual storytelling. For this three-part interview series, Clary Estes sat down with New York-based British editor and business manager Stephen Mayes to discuss the state of photojournalism. For Part I, Mayes argues that the photographic images today are not, at times, photography. 

Part II of this interview series will be published tomorrow, July 27th, 2019.


PART I PART II / PART III


Part I: This is Not a Photo  


Stephen Mayes is a New York City-based British editor and business manager working with institutions and individuals to develop effective visual storytelling since 1987. Currently, he is the Executive Director of the Tim Hetherington Trust.  

Across twenty-five years, Mayes has directed several organizations and managed the work and careers of top-level photographers and artists in the diverse areas of art, fashion, photojournalism, and commercial photography. As Creative Director of eyestorm.com, he worked with artists such as Damien Hirst, Ed Ruscha, and Richard Misrach. He also represented the archives of luminary photographers, including Robert Mapplethorpe, Steven Meisel, and David LaChapelle during his time with Art + Commerce as Director of the Image Archive. From 1985 to 1994, he worked as Director of Network Photographers in London.

In 1995, Stephen Mayes became part of the founding management team at Getty Images. His work as SVP and Group Creative Director helped launch the company as the world’s most successful image supplier. From 2004 to 2012, he was Secretary to the World Press Photo Awards Competition in Amsterdam. From 2008 to 2013, he was the CEO of VII Agency in New York.

Often described as a “futurist” Stephen has broadcast, taught and written extensively about the ethics and practice of photography and visual communication. With a focus on creative management, including project design, execution, distribution strategies, and business structures, Mayes has been at the forefront of operations for American, Asian and European imaging companies.

Don't Panic. Is image evidence? 


The Oxford dictionary defines a photograph as “A picture made using a camera, in which an image is focused on to light-sensitive material and then made visible and permanent by chemical treatment, or stored digitally.” And indeed, given the above definition, Stephen Mayes, a creative photography director, CEO and described ‘futurist’ of the photography industry, can convincingly argue that the photographic images that saturate our visual landscape today are not, at times, photography at all.

As Stephen Mayes explains: “Digital photography [in the mainstream media today] looks much the same as photography as we’ve known it for 170 years and we approach it with similar expectations. However, the indexical medium of photography has been replaced with computational processes that have thrown into question all our assumptions about the image as evidence.” He points out that the level of manipulation that can be achieved in a photographic image could easily fall under the category of science fiction.












-------------

For instance, the website, thispersondoesnotexist.com, is a Blade Runner-esque experiment in just how coequal a photograph is from a photographic image, visually. When one visits the site the viewer is immediately presented with an image of a person - one who does not exist, meanwhile, the lower right-hand corner of the frame stating, “Don’t Panic.”

The thispersondoesnotexist.com website was created by LyrnAI, a tech company developing Style-based Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), which according to their website “synthesize artificial samples, such as images, that are indistinguishable from authentic images.”  Different from Computer-generated imagery (CGI), which is the application of computer graphics to create or contribute to images dictated by the input of an outside creator, GAN technology is the computational process of an unsupervised machine deep learning technique that creates new content based on artificial intelligence. In LyrnAI’s Generating and Tuning Realistic Artificial Faces version of GAN technology, upon each refreshing of the webpage, a new “person” appears. At times, these GAN images are easy to recognize as a result of a ‘person’ having too few or too many teeth, inconsistent jewelry choices, equally odd clothing cuts, psychedelic backgrounds, or small pixelated indicators, etc., pointing towards the programs computational roots.

However, the longer the site stays up and the technology improves, the harder it becomes to recognize those criteria with the human eye.


“AI is not designed to follow orders; it is designed to think.
And from here onwards we cannot even imagine what the consequences will be."
—Stephen Mayes



The implications of generating images. Are we still in control of the images we use?


While Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies have a variety of uses outside of photojournalism, within its context, the implications of these generating images have people like Mayes pondering.

Mayes reflects: “My take is that our immediate experience of GAN imagery is crude and expresses the general belief that we are still in control of the imagery we use. People think of these technologies as super-slick expansions of Photoshop, where the artist sets some parameters and the machine obeys. The element that we have yet to come to grips with is that we are now dealing with intelligence."

He continues: "AI is not designed to follow orders; it is designed to think. And from here onwards we cannot even imagine what the consequences will be. Some (for example, Stephen Hawking and others) predict doom, others predict growth. We don’t know [what will happen], but it’s becoming clear that humans won’t be the only force in the driving seat. I’ve heard it said several times now that we don’t understand artificial intelligence any better than we understand human intelligence - ask three psychologists about how we think and you’ll hear four theories or more. We have no idea how machines think but very soon we’ll begin to see the visual expressions of that process, and unlike photography, we won’t have the benefit of shared experience to interpret the image.

At this [point] I can’t anticipate the consequences; all I can say is that the sooner we come to grips with the fact that we’re not in Kansas anymore the better we’ll be able to deal with what’s ahead. Much of the imagery will doubtless look like photography as we once knew it, but it is not at all the same.”


Stephen Mayes has observed how image-based storytelling is organically moving to different technologies and offers an example of how similar creative technologies are already accessible to the media and photojournalism industry.







AI expands into deep fake.


In July of 2017, a similar “deep fake” computational process was used to create a false, yet realistic video of former President Barack Obama giving a presentation on a school shooting that in reality never happened. As Business Insider reported in July of 2017, “Researchers at the University of Washington designed a program that can take a video of someone talking and replace their audio with something else. The result is surprisingly realistic — and completely fake.” In a TED Talk presented on July 25, 2018, computer scientist Supasorn Suwajanakorn shows how, as a grad student, he used AI and 3D modeling to create photorealistic fake videos of people synced to audio. The presentation discusses both the ethical implications and the creative possibilities of this technology as well as highlights the steps being taken to fight against its misuse.

The only certainty is change.


Mayes analyzes these new advancements and their potential effects in his essay titled, “The only certainty is change; Instability as a catalyst for creativity,” published on Viewbook in 2017 and subsequently republished in a book of collected essays called “Transformations”.

He writes: “For 170 years, photographers found roles in commerce, journalism, art and a myriad of niche specialties, yet whatever our market or form of creative expression we all accepted an extreme limitation on our function that restricted our status to that of a supplier… our business was subject to the whims of our clients who determined what they wanted, in what quantity, when and at what price. Whether selling prints to collectors, accepting commercial assignments or traveling internationally for the press our only real control was the word “no”... 

Mayes sees an opportunity in the new model of image-making. He perceives a world in which these developing technologies create new industry spaces for image-makers to wrench control from traditional power structures, which have come to dictate every level of distribution and publication, and instead reorient that control inwards by becoming publishers themselves and completely shifting the publishing pyramid to a model that could be more sustainable for the creator.

In Part 2 of this interview, we will discuss Stephen Mayes’ perspective on some of the results of introducing new technological developments for image-making and publishing in the photojournalism industry. We will also reflect on Mayes’ assertion that new image-making protocols open the door of possibilities to new methods of storytelling and subject-creator-audience engagement.

Written by Clary Estes
Editor: Adriana Teresa Letorney
Published July 26, 2019









5,497

By The Visura Media Blog —

News Reframe

In conversation with Jin Ding at IWMF about The Anja Niedringhaus Courage in Photojournalism Award

By The Visura Media Blog — The International Women Media Foundation (IWMF)— www.iwmf.org —  is a 501(c)3 non-profit organization   that offers safety..
Events News

Submit to 2020 IWMF Anja Niedringhaus Courage in Photojournalism Award via Visura

By The Visura Media Blog — Visura is honored to welcome the International Women's Media Foundation (IWMF) to the Visura community and invites female photojournalists..
News Reframe

Video: Johanna Alarcón on the power of Photography

By Directed by Adriana Teresa Letorney for Visura — Visura founder Adriana Teresa Letorney interviews Ecuadorian photojournalist Johanna Alarcón  (Johis) for this new series highlighting..
Books News

Pieter Hugo book signing for La Cucaracha on Thursday, Jan 16 at Dashwood Books in NY

By The Visura Media Blog — Dashwood Books invites you for a book signing with photographer Pieter Hugo on Thursday, January 16th from 6-8 pm.   Located at 33 Bond St New..
Events News

Exhibition: La Cucharacha by Pieter Hugo at Yossi Milo Gallery

By The Visura Media Blog — La Cucaracha January 10 – February 29, 2020 Yossi Milo Gallery 245 Tenth Avenue (between 24th & 25th St.) New York, NY 10001 Yossi Milo..
Books News

Books we recommend: The New Black Vanguard: Photography between Art and Fashion By Antwaun Sargent

By The Visura Media Blog — In The New Black Vanguard: Photography between Art and Fashion , curator and critic Antwaun Sargent addresses a radical transformation taking place..
News Spotlight

HAPPY HOLIDAYS FROM THE VISURA FAMILY!!!

By The Visura Media Blog — Dear Visura Family, Thank you. Thank you for being a part of the Visura community—and for standing with us year after year.  Thank you..
Events News

Join us at the VISURA ANNUAL BOOK SIGNING HOLIDAY PARTY on Thursday, Dec 19, 2019 at Foley Gallery in New York

By The Visura Media Blog — Hosted by Foley Gallery on Thursday, December 19th from 7:00 pm -10:00 pm— Visura & Foley Gallery are pleased to invite you to THE 2019..
Events News

Exhibition: Yamamoto Masao at Yancey Richardson

By The Visura Media Blog — Yamamoto Masao Itteki December 12, 2019 - February 8, 2020 Opening Reception and Book Signing: Thursday, December 12, 6-8 pm..
News Videos

V-Talks: Journalist and activist Ahmed Benchemsi at the Visura Salon

By The Visura Media Blog — Watch Journalist and activist Ahmed Benchemsi share his personal story and views on how the Middle East and North Africa are represented in Western..
News Reframe

on The Daring: Visura Founder Adriana Teresa Letorney - Parts of a Whole

By Interview by Ioana Friedman for The Daring — “From a tech perspective, we always have a choice. Do we want to foster respect, integrity, kindness, and unity, even when we differ? And..
Events News

Festival: FotoMéxico 2019

By The Visura Media Blog — An initiative of Centro de la Imagen: The FotoMéxico Festival presents over 100 exhibitions in museums and galleries throughout Mexico...
Events News

Exhibition: #InHonor: Monoliths by Ervin A. Johnson at Arnika Dawkins Gallery

By The Visura Media Blog — ARNIKA DAWKINS GALLERY #INHONOR: MONOLITHS 11 OCT 2019 - 7 FEB 2020 Arnika Dawkins Gallery presents native Chicagoan artist Ervin A. Johnson. A..
News Reframe

SPOTLIGHT: Antonio Pulgarin & The Sun that Frightens the Cold

By Interview by Clary Estes for The Visura Media Blog — Antonio Pulgarin is a Colombian-American lens-based artist who uses photography, photographic collage and mixed media. Recently, Pulgarin announced..
Events News

Visura announces Scout Film Festival 2020 at the Institute of Contemporary Art/Boston

By The Visura Media Blog — Visura is delighted to announce the return of Scout Film Festival for its fourth year from April 17-18, 2020! Founded by Anna Colavito and..
News Spotlight

Ecuadorian photographer Johanna "Johis" Alarcón joins the 2019 Fall Visura Mentorship Program in New York

By The Visura Media Blog — Visura is delighted to welcome 27-year-old photographer and educator Johanna "Johis" Alarcón to the invite-only 2019 Visura..
News Spotlight

SPOTLIGHT: Delphine Diallo, The Divine Feminine

By The Visura Media Blog — Editor's Note:  Delphine Diallo  is a Brooklyn-based French and Senegalese visual artist and photographer. With a focus on..
News Spotlight

Friday For Future: Young Children Protesting Climate Change

By The Visura Media Blog — Friday, September 20th, 2019—Gabriel Robert Letorney, age 5, represented the Visura.co family and joined his ps10 public school community in..
News Spotlight v_features

Reframe | Stephen Mayes & The State of Photojournalism, Part II

By Written By Clary Estes For The Visura Media Blog — Editor's note: The Reframe Column is a series of essays and interviews aimed at examining new media and visual storytelling. For this..
News Spotlight v_features

Reframe | Stephen Mayes & The State of Photojournalism, Part III

By Written by Clary Estes for The Visura Media Blog — Editor's note: The Reframe Column is a series of essays and interviews aimed at examining new media and visual storytelling. For this..
News

Introducing Team Access

By The Visura Media Blog — Collectives and groups can now collaborate on one account with multiple logins using our new Team Access  feature. Team access allows a user..
Books News Spotlight v_features

Essay & Interview | Spotlight with Joan Liftin, photographer and photo editor

By The Visura Media Blog — Editor's Note: Visura "Spotlight Series" presents interviews with visual storytellers, photo editors, curators, writers, publishers,..
Events News Spotlight

Join us tonight at the Visura Salon event starting at 7:00 PM at powerHouse Lounge in DUMBO, Brooklyn

By The Visura Media Blog — Visura is delighted to announce the participating photographers in the slideshow storytelling presentation curated by guest speaker, journalist,..
Grant Announcements

Deadline Approaching | The Visura Open Call for Visual Stories on the Middle East and North Africa

By The Visura Media Blog — The deadline for The Visura Open Call for Visual Stories on the Middle East and North Africa is approaching. The deadline is May 31, 2019. This open..
Join us
for more access